What to Do When Your Toddler Demands Breastfeeding in Public

Imagine this:
You’ve just arrived at a holiday dinner with your extended family.
You’ve prepared your breastfeeding toddler for this moment. You ran through the guest list, role-played your arrival and what to expect, and you’re feeling pretty confident that it will go smoothly.
You park the car, excitedly scoop your toddler into your arms, and waltz up to the door with ease.
You open the door and are met with sounds and sights that are familiar to you, but seem to have a different effect on your toddler.
Suddenly (and despite all of the preparation that you’ve lovingly done), they start pulling at your shirt and demanding “Mama milk”.
When you refuse, they start to tantrum, screaming loudly, and that’s when it happens: they hit you.
Grandma sees this and immediately approaches. “Where are your manners?!” she exclaims.
Shame washes over you, and any shred of confidence you had about this moment dwindles.
Thoughts begin to swirl around in your mind, leaving a sinking feeling in your gut. “I didn’t prepare them well enough for this moment. Maybe I do need to teach them more about respect. If I enforce clearer boundaries, situations like this can be avoided. This wouldn’t have happened if I’d weaned them months ago.”
For a lot of toddler breastfeeding families, the scenario outlined above is all too familiar. It can be a sore spot for families because of the nature of their toddler’s “demands”.
It often feels more intense when breastfeeding in public, where the perceived judgment of others is ubiquitous. Many parents of breastfeeding toddlers express that they feel disrespected by their child, or they’re worried about what others might think about how their child is behaving.
Let’s dive a little deeper into the concepts of “respect” and “disrespect”.
Why Your Toddler Asks to Nurse in Public: Rethinking “Disrespect”
Respect & Disrespect: Is Your Toddler Really Disrespecting You?
Respect (as a noun) is defined as “a feeling of deep admiration for someone or something that can be elicited by their abilities, qualities, or achievements.”
When we’re talking about our children and their feeling of respect for us, they’re probably not thinking too much about our abilities or achievements, but likely our qualities.
Consider these questions for a moment:
Do you think that your child has a deep admiration for you and who you are?
Do you think that when they are pulling at your shirt or demanding to breastfeed, that they are doing that because they don’t admire you, or feel connected to you, because they don’t respect you?
There is another definition of respect that usually comes up in this context, which is “a regard for the feelings, wishes, rights, or traditions of another.”
In the moment when your breastfeeding toddler pulls at your shirt, or begins demanding “Mama milk” so loudly that all heads turn in your direction while you’re standing in the food line at IKEA, that definition of respect might come to mind.
That feeling that your child is not regarding your feelings, or wishes, or rights in that moment. They don’t respect that our body is separate from theirs and we might want something different done with our body.
These feelings are valid and they are difficult.
But, when we’re talking about a toddler, is it appropriate to expect a toddler to be able to know your wishes and respect you and know the rights that you have with your body?
Long term, this is something that we want to develop in our children.
It is important. However, when dealing with a young child, it isn’t appropriate to expect them to be able to do that.
The kind of empathy needed to have the ability to have concern for someone else’s wishes and desires does not begin to develop until age 4, and even then it is very much in its infancy.
We need to consider: Is it appropriate to expect our child to be able to understand that we have a right to our own body? Especially in a moment when they’re stressed. This is not to say that it shouldn’t be modelled, but it is important to challenge our beliefs around respect and disrespect in order to understand our toddler’s experience of the world around them.
What if we look at the feeling of being disrespected when your breastfeeding toddler pulls at your shirt in a more developmentally appropriate sense?
What if we thought of respect, in that moment, as a child’s admiration for you. Their sense of connection to us. The way that they look up to us. That’s a good place to consider whether or not your child is really disrespecting you.
If you take a moment to consider that, you might be able to see more clearly how your child looks at you. You might see your child look up at you with twinkling eyes, and all feelings that your child is disrespecting you melt away.
You can see that there is a deep sense of admiration there, and an affinity for you.
That can help to ease the sense of discomfort around the feeling of being disrespected. This might create some space for you to consider the story in your mind about how your child is disrespecting you.
Even though there may be some demand around it. For example, using a loud voice.
Enter the Magic Words: “Please” and “Thank you”.
“Please” and “Thank You”: Why Breastfeeding Manners Won’t Teach a Toddler Respect

“Please” and “Thank you” are often referred to as the ‘Magic Words’. As we did before, let’s dive a little deeper into the meaning behind these words.
The word please is used to mean if you please. That’s what we are saying when we use the word please after a request. It’s really the opposite intention of the way we expect the word to be used in society.
It’s as if saying please will make something happen for you, hence its “magic” quality. If you don’t say please, then it won’t happen.
The reality is that “if you please” lets the obligation go. You are saying to the person on the receiving end of your request that they can deny it if they choose, which makes the sentiment polite.
To use the word please requires a great deal of emotional intelligence and emotion regulation.
‘Thank you’ means to express gratitude. It’s a state, a feeling, an emotion. When it becomes an obligation, it’s hollow and inauthentic.
To require a “thank you” means that you are requiring an action that doesn’t necessarily mean anything. It’s much more meaningful when that thank you actually comes from a true place of gratitude.
Teaching a child to say “thank you” isn’t necessarily teaching them to understand or reflect or cultivate gratitude and gratefulness.
If your child goes to breastfeed and you say “you can only breastfeed when you say ‘please’”, does that teach them how to respect someone else’s choices and desires?
Not really.
Or if you require them to say “thank you” after they’ve been given the breast milk, it’s not really about their internal experience and them understanding that they feel grateful and want to say thank you. It’s sophisticated social and emotional awareness which is developed over a long time.
Ways to cultivate gratitude:
Talk about the things they loved during the day
Highs and lows
Things that they were grateful for
What did you like about today?
These exercises can help develop the skill of self-reflection and get your child thinking about how it felt to enjoy moments during the day and feel truly grateful about them.
How to Stop Toddler Breastfeeding in Public? Why Rewards and Punishments Backfire
Rewards and Punishments: What Psychology Says About Breastfeeding Behaviour
Using praise and rewards to encourage the behaviours you want to see and using consequences to discourage the behaviours that you don’t want to see is taking a behavioural approach to your toddler’s actions around breastfeeding (i.e. shirt pulling, tantrums, biting, hitting, etc.).
In our modern parenting world today, many parents are beginning to move away from using punishment to stop “undesirable” behaviours, instead opting for natural consequences or logical consequences. When talking about breastfeeding manners, often it’s more the “reward and praise” side that parents fall on.
Think gentle parenting, responsive parenting, conscious parenting, etc. Many people in those camps shy away from using punishments.
I want to share with you that the popular culture understanding around rewards and punishments isn’t true to the psychological understanding of rewards and punishments. In everyday language, we tend to hear “positive” as good and “negative” as bad. In psychology, “positive” simply means adding something and “negative” simply means removing something. When we’re talking about rewards and punishments, there are really two elements to consider:
Reinforcement: An attempt to increase the likelihood of a specific outcome. Usually a “good” or desirable behaviour.
Positive reinforcement: adding something desirable to increase the likelihood of the desired behaviour
Negative reinforcement: removing something unpleasant to increase the likelihood of the desired behaviour
Punishment: Something that is done to decrease the likelihood of an undesirable behaviour
Positive punishment: adding something unpleasant to decrease the likelihood of the behaviour you don’t want
Negative punishment: removing something desirable to decrease the likelihood of the behaviour you don’t want
Reinforcement and punishment are often two sides of the same coin. When you reward the behaviour you want to see, there’s a flip side to that reward: losing it, or going without it, when you don’t see that behaviour. Most often, parents are actually focusing on the negative behaviour. They are trying to use a reward to stop the negative behaviour, so they’re focused - again - on that negative behaviour.

For example, if you’re using a sticker chart to reward your child every time they don’t pull on your shirt when they want to breastfeed, that is adding something desirable to increase the likelihood of a certain behaviour. That is positive reinforcement. But the flip side is that when they do pull on your shirt, the opportunity for that sticker is taken away, or the reward is lost.
That is removing something desirable to decrease the likelihood of a behaviour, which is negative punishment.
In both cases, the chart is organized around the unwanted behaviour.
Withholding works the same way.
If you withhold breast milk until your child says “please”, you’re removing something they want in order to decrease that behaviour. This is also negative punishment. This then creates a cycle of using negative experiences to try to encourage positive behaviour.
When This Becomes a Problem: Impulse Control and Stress in Toddlers
Your child doesn’t begin to develop impulse control until about age 4.
And this is just the beginning. They are working on that impulse control until about age 25 (and even then can require support).
If you are using punishments and rewards to support your child, then changing their behaviour is actually outside of their control. They have an extremely difficult time stopping themselves from doing something that might not be desirable in your eyes.
They also aren’t consciously able to move themselves from a state of stress to a state of calm.
Often, parents want to get rid of those stress behaviours: the kicking, pulling, not using please and thank you.
When they are in a stress state, they will not act in a calm way.
Those are the behaviours we don’t like. Those are the behaviours we’re looking to remove the positive things around, and make sure we’re not reinforcing the behaviour.
So we’re waiting until they’re in a calm state to reward their behaviour so that we can reinforce the “good” behaviour.
But in actuality, they are not in conscious control of their ability to regulate their stress. They require co-regulation to move themselves from a state of stress to a state of calm.
That means that their impulses - hitting, kicking, screaming are not within their control. So using this behavioural mindset of withholding the good things until they control themselves backfires.
For a lot of parents who use that approach, it starts to “work” around age 5-7, which is when they are developmentally able to have concern for others’ feelings and desires, AND have the ability to change their actions accordingly (at least some of the time), even when their autonomic nervous system has them feeling a strong urge to “fight”. And even then, it is just the beginning.
It is very difficult not to take a behavioural approach to our children’s actions, especially when our culture is steeped in this kind of thinking, especially around parenting.
When you have that feeling of “What are others thinking about me?” it can really feel like you have no choice but to praise the desirable behaviour and withhold during the undesirable behaviour.
Being in Public With a Toddler Pulling Your Shirt: What to Do Instead
What Can You Do for Your Child When They Are Demanding to Breastfeed in Public?
All humans do better when they can. When breastfeeding in public feels stressful, it can help to start by asking what your child needs in that moment
So why are they pulling on your shirt? Are they stressed? Are they overwhelmed? Are they hungry? Are they thirsty? Are they too hot? Are they too cold? Are they bored? Are they feeling disconnected from you? What is going on that is causing them to have that behaviour?
Co-regulate with them.
Take a moment to breathe deeply and approach the situation from a place of safety and rest. It is your emotional state that is physiologically shared with them. They can see that in your posture, the love in your smile, and their emotions being mirrored back to them through your facial expressions.
Model the behaviour that you want to encourage them to develop.
This is not about the action of being polite. It’s actually feeling the respect for someone else. Expressing genuine concern for someone else who might be experiencing something that is different from what they are experiencing. That is a huge part of empathy. And that begins around age 4.
When you take a moment to consider your child’s needs at any given moment, that is modelling empathy.
“Children learn empathy both from watching us and from experiencing our empathy for them. When we empathize with our children, they develop trusting, secure attachment with us. Those attachments are key to their wanting to adopt our values and to model our behaviour and therefore building their empathy for others.” Harvard - Making Caring Common Project
Identify your child’s need in the moment.
For example, if they are pulling at your shirt, you might get curious and ask “would you like some mommy milk? You can ask mommy ‘may I have some mommy milk?’”. You do not have to withhold breastmilk until they say please or thank you. Instead, you notice their need and model how to have their needs met in the future instead of focusing on their behaviour. This allows your child to calm themselves through co-regulation.
What Can You Do for Yourself When Your Toddler Asks to Nurse in Public?

Keep yourself safe and taken care of.
Even identifying and meeting one need can make a big difference in how you manage a situation.
Ask yourself: What needs do I have in this moment? If you’re thirsty, tired, stressed out from other things, then it’s going to be harder to find your calm in that moment. Do you need some connection with friends? Do you need a drink of water? Have you eaten today?
Reduce physical sources of discomfort.
Are you comfortable in the moment? Are you hot in that moment? Do you need a drink of water? Do you need to move to the shade? Is it time to go? Are you feeling tired
Something that can be happening to you in a very physical sense is shirt pulling. Sometimes there’s scratching happening. Can you keep your child’s nails short, so that it doesn’t feel like that on your body?
These suggestions can help you work on finding your calm in the overwhelm. Even if your child has feelings about the choices you make in the moment, once you attend to your needs, they will benefit from your calm state.
I also want to add that there are times when the disrespectful behaviour is not coming from your child, but from other adults (who should be developmentally able to respect your autonomy as a person, and parent, separate from themselves with the right and ability to make your own choices.) I have a separate blog post and podcast episode on navigating judgment from others that is made to help you navigate those specific interactions.
Putting It All Together: A Calmer Holiday Dinner
Let’s go back to the story at the beginning of this post.
You’ve arrived at a holiday dinner with your extended family.
You’ve prepared your breastfeeding toddler for this moment.
You ran through the guest list, role-played your arrival, and what to expect.
Before you open the door, you take a deep breath in and let it go.
You take a second to think about your needs in that moment. It’s been a long car ride, and you need to use the washroom or take a sip of water before greeting everyone, so you briefly excuse yourself and your toddler for a few minutes.
You ask them if they need a sip of water, too. They agree, and you both take a moment to meet your needs.
This allows you to get familiar with the location of your dinner and take a look around. You bring your toddler in for a hug and whisper, “I love you”, and they relax into your embrace.
As Grandma approaches, you smile warmly and greet her. “Thank you for inviting us. The food smells delicious!”
Your warmth is reciprocated, and your toddler witnesses this interaction, wiring their brain and body for safety.
After a few greetings, you find a quiet space and sit with your child. Sensing an opportunity for connection, you ask, “Would you like some mama milk?”
After a short breastfeeding session, your child, feeling safe and connected, begins to explore their surroundings, offering smiles and greetings to family and friends.
You feel at ease and confident to meet your and your child’s needs for the rest of your visit.
As much as this may seem like a bit of a far-fetched fantasy, I promise you, it is possible to find this kind of ease in your parenting, breastfeeding, and weaning. I share a lot more about this in my free workshop.



Comments